Hip and Thigh: Smiting Theological Philistines with a Great Slaughter. Judges 15:8

Wednesday, December 27, 2006

Musical Tastes: My Personal Adventures in Music (pt. 3)

Introducing CCM

Every now and then I have been writing about my musical tastes and convictions.

With the last post on this subject I wrote about my love for secular rock and roll and pop-music and how that love came into conflict with attending a fundamental Baptist style church. Because dislike for secular music ran high where I attended, I kept my secular music interests pretty much between myself and my bedside alarm clock radio that was set to the local, popular music radio station.

In the summer of my 9th grade year of school in 1983, I attended a Methodist youth camp in Missouri. There I was introduced for the first time to Contemporary Christian Music. It wasn't much; just Amy Grant's album, Age to Age, that contained the El Shaddai song everyone who was into sappy sounding mellow music really liked. The female youth/choir director at our Methodist church thought Amy was "the bomb," and everyone who loved Jesus should love her equally as well. The feeling was never mutual with me. I still preferred my Duran Duran and Police over Amy "Grunt."

Then, in the summer before my 10th grade year, my family moved from Missouri to Arkansas. This is when we started attending the more solid but fundamentalist church that didn't care for secular music. Interestingly, they didn't care for CCM either. I don't know if that was a matter of preference or the fact CCM was still gaining popularity among Christians and they weren't familiar with it.

When my family moved to Arkansas from Missouri, I left behind a really good friend. This friend also shared my enjoyment of popular rock and roll music. I kept in marginal contact with him during the first 6 months or so in my new home. One weekend, my family and I returned to my former hometown to visit my grandmother and move down some items we had left at her house. When I arrived, I called on my old friend and discovered he had become a "Christian" and attended a Pentecostal holiness church with several of my other previous friends. I also was stunned to see he had grown his hair out really long and listened exclusively to CCM. He gave me a major lecture on the wickedness of secular music and that as a Christian he only wanted to listen to rock and roll music that praised Jesus.

Being an impressionable young man, I took his anti-rock preaching to heart and thought I would give this CCM alternative a listen. In fact, I took his preaching so much to heart that I even "rededicated" my life to Christ at my new church and had myself baptized.

One of the bands he suggested I should listen to was Petra. I gave my mother a list of CCM albums I wanted and I received three for Christmas: Petra's Beat the System, Michael W. Smith's 2 and Bryan Duncan's Have Yourself Committed. As time went on, I accumulated several others, like Mylon Le Fevre, Carmen, and Whiteheart. Eventually, I picked up the Christian metal bands like Guardian, Whitecross, and Stryper (which I will go into more detail with a later post). Yet, all the while I was collecting this Christian music, I was thinking I was being spiritual because I listened to it over the secular stuff.

There is one amusing side note to my new found CCM interest. My old friend told me when he graduated high school he was moving to Nashville, becoming a roadie for Petra, would learn the CCM business, and then form his own Christian rock band. He invited me to join him. At the time I thought that sounded awesome. In order to completely accomplish this venture, my friend had started learning to play the guitar. I in turn came back to Arkansas and began taking piano lessons from the church organist, because I wanted to play one of those really cool Yamaha keyboard sets I saw in all the videos. I even stopped cutting my hair so I could get it that "rock and roll" performance length.

My parents were extremely supportive of my new found cultural interest in learning piano until I told them I was planning on using my piano playing to start a Christian rock band after I graduated high school, rather than attending college. They quickly crushed my Christian band plans with my buddy. I kept growing my hair out long, however.

At any rate, even though I liked CCM, I always felt as though it was a step or so below secular music in quality and performance. I would even say that some of it was just outright lame. The music was poorly performed by the bands and the albums were terribly produced. CCM fans always suggested that these albums could be used as witnessing tools, like an audio tract that shared the gospel. A troubled youth who would otherwise not attend a church or read a Bible would at least listen to a rock album, even if it were a Christian rock band. But I was embarrassed by the quality of some of the music that I didn't want my lost friends to necessarily know I listened to it. So, even though I purchased CCM, I still had a stash of my favorite secular stuff I also listened to.

In the fall of 87, I went to college and one of my first objectives I had was to find a group of Christians who also shared my enthusiasm for CCM. I found them at the Baptist Student Union at Arkansas State. God, however, in His irony, used my BSU experience to bring me to Christ and genuine salvation. The final week of my freshman year, God was pleased to save me, and then my perspective on music entirely changed.

Upon giving my life to Christ, some of my supportive friends held a "barrel burning" where I took all the secular music I still clung to and trashed it. My music library was now only CCM. But, a few months or so after I started my sophomore year of college as a brand new Christian, a couple of my friends challenged me about my CCM. They gave me a book by a guy named Jeff Godwin called Dancing with Demons: The music's real master. In this book, the author, a Jack Chick taught disciple, argues that all rock music, regardless if it is sung by secular pagans or zealous Christians, is Satanic in origins and is designed to only enslave those who willing listened to it. He cataloged many CCM groups of that time (late 80s) and wrote anecdotal, hearsay style stories about how they really lived corrupted lives and lied about the true intentions of their so-called music "ministries." He even alleged that Petra's lead singer often gave Satanic signals to the audience when they performed.

I was stunned. I couldn't believe many of my CCM heroes were really deceptive liars. Thankfully, I took his claims with the proverbial grain of salt. I also came in contact with KJV onlyists hyper-fundamentalist, David Cloud, who wrote exposes' and taught about the evils of CCM. His website to this day still has many of his articles and essays condemning all CCM as detrimental to the Christian faith. In a similar fashion that Godwin does, Cloud will list anecdotal stories about how these performers really live double lives or are involved with some false teaching or some supposed Christian compromise that only leads young minds away from the Lord.

Jeff Godwin and David Cloud are not alone in their criticism of CCM. There are several, mainly from the independent, fundamental camp, who act as theological mullahs warning of the dangerous CCM poses to Christian youth.

Three things always troubled me about these CCM critics:

First is the second and third hand testimony about what a certain CCM performer did or said. Anecdotal and hearsay stories is exactly the best way to describe what really amounts to gossip on the part of these critics. Rarely is there any firsthand accounts substantiated by genuine facts. David Cloud, for example, will still publish an occasional article on his Daily Article Listings page that criticizes various CCM artists. The weird thing about his critiques is how often they will be 10 years out of date. He may complain about something the lead singer from the CCM group Third Day said in an interview in 1998. Cloud then infers what he thinks is compromise on the part of the person's statement and proclaims him and his CCM group as apostate in this present day. The problem with this approach is not only is it out of date, but often it is misinformed as to the current day status of the person under review. What a person said or did 10 years ago may not reflect what that same person, after 10 years of spiritual maturity, says or does now.

Second is how these CCM artists are judged and condemned according to fundamentalist preference standards. Independent fundamentalists have a ridiculous understanding as to what constitutes compromise and who is allegedly involved in compromise. Generally it stems from their inadequate beliefs about a contrived doctrine called "the doctrine of separation." A person's actions or affiliations are considered "worldly" and according to independent fundamentalists, anyone who is a sober-minded and seriously spiritual Christian will recognize the person's worldliness and thus separate from him or her. The separation is practiced by not having any personal affiliations with the "worldly" individual, and is extended to not having any affiliations with other Christians who may have affiliations with the "worldly" individual.

Independent fundamentalists apply this inept view of "separation" to CCM artists and any contemporary music that may be used as worship in a local Church. Hence, if Steve Camp performs at a venue where a Catholic moral activist may have given a lecture the day before, Steve Camp is to be separated from because he compromised the gospel by participating and performing at the same venue. If at a later time, Steve Camp ministers at a local Church, that local Church is to be separated from because they had Steve Camp perform.

Additionally, independent fundamentalists equate contemporary music with worldly music and if a Church uses contemporary music in a worship service, then the Church is compromising with the world according to "the doctrine of separation." It doesn't matter if the Church is solid doctrinally and theologically and proclaims high the Gospel of Jesus Christ, the fact that contemporary music is considered "worldly" and the Church uses it on occasion in the worship service places them in the position of compromise. This view of CCM is not only unsupported by scripture, but is based solely upon what has become the accepted preference on the part of fundamentalists critical of current day events.

And third, rarely do these CCM critics provide examples of the kind of music a Christian should listen to and enjoy. Some critics are so harsh that a reader is left with the impression a Christian should never listen to any music what so ever. It is almost like an Islamic view of musical arts. For instance, I am yet to read from David Cloud what he believes is a positive example of good, God honoring music.

Again, those CCM critics who will suggest the kind of music Christians can listen to without sliding down into apostasy, tend to only offer their preferences as to what THEY believe is good music. Because of their misguided view of what constitutes "worldly" and "compromise," they by default believe anything performed in a contemporary style is "worldly." As a substitute, they will suggest gospel quartet performers who happen to come from fundamentalist backgrounds. But, as I will explore in greater depth later, the style of music performed does not necessarily equate with "good" and "God-honoring." In fact, much of it is, at least in my opinion, just as lame, if not worse in performance quality, than some of those CCM bands I listened to back when I was in high school. Moreover, the lyrics have deplorable theological content and only make me angry when I hear them sung.

Is CCM artists above criticism? Of course not. I believe CCM artists have done and do plenty to raise concerns for Christians. However, we must have a proper, scripturally informed criticism of CCM, not one born out of personal preferences that have been shaped by a phony fundamentalist spirituality. Judging CCM according to this false standard only serves to damaged the credibility of the one leveling criticisms, and if those criticisms are legitimate, no one will take them seriously.

Labels: ,


Anonymous Anonymous said...

hey Fred, really enjoyed this post. I can really relate to your musical journey and look forward to your future posts on this issue.

Also, thanks for all the hard work you do in writing these blogs. Remember, even if you don't get 150+ comments like the Pyro guys, there are people out there who (like me) regularly read your posts but don't always leave comments. Keep it up bro! Also, I listened to many of your lectures online and benefitted from them as well.

2:45 PM, December 27, 2006  
Blogger Gummby said...

I guess I better keep my mouth shut until I know where you're headed with the whole music thing.

But I just wanted to say that I saw Petra first in 1985, back when Smitty was opening for them...him and his band were still jumping around on stage in basketball jerseys and a Gumby head. It was the Beat the System tour--the last tour with Greg X. Volz.

6:19 PM, December 27, 2006  
Blogger Fred Butler said...

Thanks Mike for the kind remarks. I am glad you have enjoyed the blog. I glanced over yours and later this week when I have some time, I hope to check out those articles you wrote to Dave on OEC.


I saw Petra on the Back to the Street tour right when they had the new singer. I also saw them at a later time when they had the new bassist and right before the keyboardist guy left. (Sorry, I can't recall all their names at the moment).
I hope you will be pleased as to where I am going. It isn't bad. (c;


7:19 PM, December 27, 2006  
Blogger pilgrim said...

A lot of CCM is not very good musically--some is fluff--but to dismiss it all the way those books do is neither correct nor helpful.

I have said before that attacking something so importnat to somebody without first giving an alternative is not helpful--and not effective most of the time--they may for a time fall in with your crowd--but most will leave it sooner than later.

I also find such books dishonest and poorly researched. I have flipped through them and seen many inaccuracies--including getting lyrics wrong--even when the lyrics are printed with the album. If they can't get that simple stuff right--why should I listen to them?
ANd they often use fanciful interpretations of what the words "really" mean--and I shake my head and go "HUH?!?"

9:09 AM, December 29, 2006  
Blogger davidcwelker said...

Very interesting post. I'll have to browse your blog some more. Thanks for discussing this issue.

7:09 AM, January 03, 2007  
Blogger Coldie said...

I would have to say that the only music I think and msot IFB believe is God Honoring are hymns. I use to listen to everything, I hated classical, but loved any other typ of music, then I got saved, and my husband was alredy saved, and we listened to CCM music, but do you know what it takes to be calssified as a " Christian Rock Band"? All you need to do is say Jesus name a few times, and your a shoe in. That in its self should turn you away. But hey God gave you free will, and if you choose to use it, then you are the one who has to answer to Him, not anyone eles, so dont take somone other persons advice on it, cause at the Judgment Seat, you have to answer for you, God won't care if johnny boy told you to do it, you choose to do it =) Have a Blessed Day!

3:01 AM, April 10, 2007  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home